Sunday, October 1, 2023

Public Land Hunters Win Nook Crossing Case in Wyoming

The nook crossing battle in Wyoming appears to be over, and public land hunters, no less than for now, have gained. At this time the District Courtroom of Wyoming discovered that it’s authorized to cross from one nook of public land to a different nook of public land, whereas stepping via non-public airspace.

The ruling comes after 4 hunters crossed a nook of the Elk Mountain Ranch, which is held by Iron Bar Holdings, managed by billionaire Fred Eshelman. Iron Bar Holdings introduced prison trespass expenses (which the hunters beat final 12 months), and filed a civil swimsuit in federal court docket claiming that the trespassing diminished the ranch’s property worth. The ranch claimed the lads brought on greater than $7 million in damages.

Chief U.S. District Decide Scott W. Skavdahl dominated in favor of 4 hunters who crossed a nook of the Elk Mountain Ranch.

The Order states: “. . . the Courtroom finds that the place an individual nook crosses on foot throughout the checkerboard from public land to public land with out touching the floor of personal land and with out damaging non-public property, there isn’t any legal responsibility for trespass.”

In the event you haven’t been following this case carefully, nook crossing means strolling from one nook of public land to a different nook of public, crossing diagonally between corners of personal land, with out ever setting foot on non-public property. Phillip Yeomans, Bradly Cape, John Slowensky, and Zachary Smith, all of Missouri (and nicknamed the Missouri 4), used a small stepladder to cross from one parcel of public land to a different whereas on a hunt in 2021 and in 2020. 

checkerboard public land
The West is a checkerboard of private and non-private land. Andrew McKean

The truth that the hunters gained the civil case may have broad implications for public land hunters in Wyoming. 

“It was a fairly full throated endorsement of the principal that so long as you don’t contact non-public land or trigger hurt to non-public land ultimately, then you’ve the appropriate to cross corner-to-corner of public lands,” says Eric Hanson, an lawyer who represented Backcountry Hunters and Anglers on their amicus temporary on this litigation. 

Nonetheless, the ruling doesn’t imply that nook crossing in each state is now authorized. It’s additionally doable that different non-public landowners may carry nook crossing civil fits, Hanson says. 

“This has to work its manner up the chain of appeals earlier than it turns into extra binding,” Hanson says. “This can be a massive first step, but it surely’s not essentially going to use outdoors of Wyoming. The court docket was very cautious to place this in simply the context of the case, not a nationwide context” 

However nonetheless BHA and the general public land hunters of Wyoming have purpose to have a good time. 

“At this time was a win for the folks, each in Wyoming and throughout the nation,” says BHA president Land Tawny. “The court docket’s ruling confirms that it was authorized for the Missouri 4 to step from public land to public land over a shared public/non-public nook. Coupled with current laws handed by the Wyoming legislature, we’re comfortable that widespread sense and the rule of regulation prevailed. Backcountry Hunters & Anglers applauds the court docket’s cautious balancing of entry to public land and respect of personal property rights. We expect to find extra options to entry – collectively.”

Over course, the 4 hunters who’ve been battling these instances for years even have purpose to have a good time.

“This can be a lengthy overdue and singularly nice final result for your entire American public and anyone who enjoys public lands,” the hunters’ lawyer Ryan Semerad advised WyoFile. Semerad says they “absolutely anticipate” an attraction.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles